Pentucket Regional School District School Committee  Minutes 2007

 

January 2, 2007 January 16, 2007

January 30, 2007

February 6, 2007 February 13, 2007 March 6, 2007
March 20, 2007 April 3, 2007 April 17, 2007
May 1, 2007 May 15, 2007 June 5, 2007
July 17, 2007 August 14, 2007 September 4, 2007
September 18, 2007 November 6, 2007 November 20, 2007
December 4, 2007 December 18, 2007

 

January 2, 2007

PENTUCKET REGIONAL SCHOOL COMMITTEE

    High School

    January 2, 2007

 Members Present: Chairman Moran, Mrs. Albert, Mr. Levine, Mr. Fournier, Mrs. Piccolomini,

Mr. Baker, Mrs. Corradino, Mr. Baumgardner, Ms. Blades, and Mr. Deveau

 Also Present: Dr. Livingston, Dr. McGinn

 Call to Order: Chairman Moran called the meeting to order at 7:30 p.m.

Roll Call: Roll call was taken. The majority vote was 5.7. Mr. Atwood was absent.

Mr. Levine led the Committee in the Pledge of Allegiance.

 Agenda

Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Levine and seconded by Ms. Blades to accept the agenda as amended.  The first amendment was to inform the Committee on the dates that the Finance Directors from each town planned to meet to discuss the budget and distribute a sign up sheet for members to attend the meetings. The second amendment was to move the FY08 budget up to the second item under new business. Ms. Blades wanted it stated in the record that she preferred the budget to be the first item under new business. The third amendment was to have a brief discussion on the Melanson and Heath audit. The final amendment was to have a status on the Business Office. The status was to include accounts payable, staffing, any vacancies, and coverage of the Chief Financial Officer duties. Motion carried. (for: Moran, Levine, Baumgardner, Corradino, Blades, Piccolomini, Fournier, Albert, Deveau, Baker)(abstained: Grazio)(for: 10.1)(abstained: 1.1)

 Minutes

Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Levine and seconded by Mr. Baumgardner to accept and file the minutes of December 19, 2006 as amended. The first amendment was on page one: Ms. Blades voted opposed on the vote to accept and file the correspondence. The second amendment was on page three, third paragraph: Ms. Blades wanted the word “perhaps” removed. The last amendment was on page three under Special Education: Ms. Blades wanted “as asked when original decision was made” added to the last sentence. Motion failed. (for: Blades, Levine, Fournier, Baker)(opposed: Corradino, Albert, Baumgardner, Deveau, Piccolomini, Moran)(abstained: Grazio) (for: 4.1)(opposed: 6.0)(abstained: 1.1)

 Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Baker and seconded by Mr. Levine to accept and file the minutes of December 19, 2006 as written. Motion carried. (for: Levine, Fournier, Baker, Corradino, Albert, Baumgardner, Deveau, Piccolomini, Moran)(opposed: Blades)(abstained: Grazio) (for:9.0)(opposed: 1.1)(abstained: 1.1)

 Correspondence

Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Levine and seconded by Mr. Baumgardner to accept and file the correspondence. Motion carried. (for: Levine, Fournier, Baker, Corradino, Albert, Baumgardner, Deveau, Piccolomini, Grazio, Moran)(opposed: Blades)(for: 10.1)(opposed: 1.1)

Ms. Blades wanted it stated in the record that this is the third packet that does not have Mr. Collins’ email and budget in.

Recognition – Page School Student Council

Melissa Reynolds-Comeau and Jessica Jancsy came to the meeting with 10 students from the Student Council. They spoke on the many projects that the students are working on as a council.

 The Sweetsir School presentation was postponed.

 New Business

Chairman Moran mentioned that the Finance Directors from the three towns have identified the nights that they would like the School Committee to attend to discuss the FY08 budget. Mrs. Moran passed around a sign up sheet and requested that there be a representative from each town at each meeting.

Business Office Update

Dr. Livingston reported that the Procurement Officer’s duties are being covered in the office by Ms. McWilliams and Dr. Livingston. Mrs. Grazio reminded the Committee that the Committee did vote for the Business Manager to be the Chief Procurement Officer. The Committee questioned whether or not that vote needed to be rescinded. Dr. Livingston said that the Committee is a procuring authority. And that they may choose to either delegate that authority to the business office or retain the authority themselves.

 Dr. Livingston commented that the district is operating within a 30 to 45 day window on accounts payables. There is a temporary person filling in for payroll with a consultant available if necessary. Dr. Livingston said that he viewed the Committee, the Finance Subcommittee, and the State Control Board as adequate checks and balances.

 Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Levine and seconded by Ms. Blades to have a Business Office Status Report included in all future Superintendent Reports that are sent out through the packets. Motion carried. (unanimous approval)  

Mr. Collins is currently on a paid administrative leave. Mr. Baker wanted it stated in the record that he has a “real problem paying salaries without getting work”.

 Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Baker and seconded by Mr. Levine that during the interim period when the District does not have a Chief Financial Officer, the District Accountant is expected to report what she knows in the way of exceptions and problems to the School Committee as part of her responsibilities for the time that is doing the Chief Financial Officer’s job. Motion carried. (for: Levine, Fournier, Baker, Corradino, Albert, Baumgardner, Deveau, Blades, Grazio, Moran)(abstained: Piccolomini)(for: 10.1)(abstained: 1.1)

 Strategic Plan Goals

Dr. Livingston presented the Committee with a recommended list of goals for the strategic plan FY07 – FY09.

 Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Fournier and seconded by Mrs. Grazio to have each Committee member forward a list of their goals to Marianne Naffah by January 31st for the February 6th packet. Motion carried. (for: Levine, Moran, Grazio, Baumgardner, Baker, Fournier, Corradino)(opposed: Albert, Blades, Piccolomini, Deveau)(for: 7.4)(opposed: 3.8)

 Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mrs. Albert and seconded by Mrs. Piccolomini to accept the strategic plan goals for FY07 – FY09 as recommended by the Superintendent in conjunction with the district report card. Motion carried. (for: Corradino, Albert, Piccolomini, Fournier, Moran, Deveau)(opposed: Blades, Baumgardner, Levine, Grazio)(abstained: Baker)(for: 6.0)(opposed: 4.4)(abstained: .8)

 FY08 Budget Updated Timeline

Dr. Livingston gave members an updated 2008 Fiscal Year Budget Timeline.

 Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Baker and seconded by Mr. Levine to accept the amended budget timeline as presented by Dr. Livingston. Motion carried. for: Levine, Fournier, Baker, Corradino, Albert, Baumgardner, Deveau, Blades, Piccolomini, Moran)(opposed: Grazio)(for: 10.1)(opposed: 1.1)

 Motion/Vote

It was moved by Ms. Blades and seconded by Mr. Levine to have all power point presentations included in the packets prior to the meeting and to have all presentations from December be included in the next packet along with the special education presentation and the school improvement plan presentation. Motion carried. (Levine, Corradino, Grazio, Blades, Piccolomini, Baker, Deveau, Fournier)(opposed: Albert, Moran, Baumgardner)(for: 8.2)(opposed: 3.0)

 Mrs. Grazio suggested it be sent the way people would like to receive it whether electronically or a paper copy and to have a paper copy in the public packet and permanent record.

 FY08 Budget

Dr. Livingston did a presentation on the FY08 budget. Members asked questions regarding the district wide special education coordinator, custodial supplies, special education contracted services, computers, town assessments, and full day kindergarten. The Chairman informed the Committee that the budget was in draft form and that the public hearing will be held on January 16th and there will be another work session on the budget on January 30th.  Chairman Moran asked Dr. Livingston and Ms. McWilliams to review the revenue and community contribution accounts.

 Mrs. Grazio left the meeting at 9:30. The majority vote changed to 5.1.

 Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Baker and seconded by Mr. Levine to request that the fiscal 2007 and 2008 budgets delineate circuit-breaker information in a consistent manner. Motion carried. (for: Piccolomini, Fournier, Blades, Levine, Corradino, Moran, Albert, Baker, Deveau)(opposed: Baumgardner)(for: 9.0)(opposed: 1.1)

 Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Levine and seconded by Mr. Baumgardner to continue the meeting after 10:00 p.m. Motion carried. (for: Piccolomini, Fournier, Baumgardner, Levine, Corradino, Moran, Albert, Baker, Deveau)(opposed: Blades)(for: 9.0)(opposed: 1.1)

  Home School Request

Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Baker and seconded by Mr. Levine to approve the home school request as presented by Dr. McGinn. Motion carried. (unanimous approval)

Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Levine and seconded by Mrs. Piccolomini to table the remainder of the agenda except the superintendent’s goals. Motion failed. (for: Levine, Fournier, Deveau, Baker)(opposed: Baumgardner, Moran, Corradino, Albert)(abstained: Piccolomini)(for: 3.8)(opposed: 4.1)(abstained: 1.1)

 The contract for the ESP’s (Unit D) will be edited in the central office on Wednesday, January 3rd and delivered to the Committee that afternoon.

 Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Baker and seconded by Mrs. Albert to suspend the policy that the Committee receive this ESP contract two weeks ahead of ratifying it. Motion carried. (for: Piccolomini, Fournier, Blades, Levine, Corradino, Moran, Albert, Baumgardner, Deveau)(opposed: Blades)(for: 9.0)(opposed: 1.1)

 Superintendent Goals

Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mrs. Albert and seconded by Mrs. Piccolomini to approve the superintendent goals. Motion carried. (for: Moran, Baumgardner, Corradino, Piccolomini, Fournier, Albert, Deveau)(opposed: Blades)(abstained: Levine, Baker)(for: 7.1)(opposed: 1.1)(abstained: 1.9)  

Finance Subcommittee Minutes

Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Levine and seconded by Mr. Baumgardner to accept the minutes from the December 19th finance subcommittee meeting. Motion carried. (for: Moran, Baumgardner, Corradino, Piccolomini, Levine, Fournier, Albert, Deveau)(abstained: Blades, Baker)(for: 8.2)(abstained: 1.9)

 It was noted that the minutes from the last several finance subcommittee meetings have been taken and approved by the subcommittee except one set. They have not yet been forwarded to the full Committee for approval.

 Revolving Account Report

Ms. McWilliams gave members and updated report on the revolving accounts.

 Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Levine and seconded by Mrs. Piccolomini to have a revolving account updated report included with the monthly financial report sent out in the packet. Motion carried. (unanimous approval)

 Melanson and Heath Audit

Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Baumgardner and seconded by Mr. Levine to send the District Attorney’s Office the Melanson and Heath Audit and to ask them if they have any recommendations. Motion carried. (unanimous approval)

 Executive Session

Motion/Vote

It was moved to enter into executive session for the purposes of discussing both union and non union contract negotiations. Motion carried by roll call vote. (for: Piccolomini, Fournier, Blades, Levine, Corradino, Moran, Albert, Baumgardner, Deveau)(opposed: Blades)(for: 9.0)(opposed: 1.1)

 Adjournment

Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Baker and seconded by Mr. Levine to adjourn the meeting at 11:00 p.m.

Motion carried. (unanimous approval)

Respectfully submitted,

 Marianne Naffah

Recording Secretary


January 16, 2007

PENTUCKET REGIONAL SCHOOL COMMITTEE

                                                                                                            High School

                                                                                                            January 16, 2007

 

Members Present: Chairman Moran, Mrs. Albert, Mr. Levine, Mr. Fournier, Mrs. Piccolomini,

Mr. Baker, Mrs. Corradino, Mr. Baumgardner, Ms. Blades, Mr. Atwood, and Mr. Deveau

 Also Present: Dr. Livingston, Dr. McGinn

 Call to Order: Chairman Moran called the meeting to order at 7:35 p.m.

 Roll Call: Roll call was taken. The majority vote was 5.5. Mrs. Grazio was absent.

 Mr. Levine led the Committee in the Pledge of Allegiance.

 Agenda

Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Levine and seconded by Mr. Baumgardner to accept the agenda as amended.  The amendment was to add a discussion on retention to a future meeting. Motion carried. (unanimous approval)

 Minutes

Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Levine and seconded by Mr. Baumgardner to accept and file the minutes of January 2, 2007. Motion carried. (for: Levine, Fournier, Baker, Corradino, Albert, Baumgardner, Deveau, Piccolomini, Moran)(opposed: Blades)(abstained: Atwood) (for: 9.0)(opposed: 1.1)(abstained: .8)

 Correspondence

Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Levine and seconded by Mr. Baker to accept and file the correspondence. Motion carried. (unanimous approval)

 Ms. Blades stated that the memo from the Whittier Regional Vocational Technical High School should be discussed at the January 30th meeting.

 Presentation of FY08 Budget

Dr. Livingston gave a brief power point presentation on the proposed FY08 budget. He reviewed the values, mission statement, and beliefs. Dr. Livingston said there is a proposed 3.8% increase. He reviewed the proposed staffing increases, custodial parity and the increases at the middle school and high school level.

 Public Hearing

Mr. Torrisi, West Newbury , gave a brief proposal on improvements to the middle school gymnasium. It included safety and facility concerns, letters of support, a plan, and the cost. He asked the Committee to consider this with the FY08 budget proposal. The project would cost approximately $50,000.

 Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Atwood and seconded by Mrs. Piccolomini to direct Dr. Livingston and the Business Office to investigate Mr. Torrisi’s proposal and come back to the School Committee with recommendations. There were several amendments. First, to have this motion include all building projects with a prioritized list. Second, to discuss and form a capital improvements subcommittee before the end of March. Third, to have Dr. Livingston review the stabilization fund for this project. Motion carried. (unanimous approval)

 Ms. Reynolds introduced herself and the other members on the Special Education Parent Advisory Council.

 Mr. Labrecque commended the Superintendent on the parity between the elementary schools. He also mentioned concern with the community contribution being over 2.5%. Ms. Blades asked Mr. Labrecque about his comfort level with the additional Chapter 70 aid. He responded that he would be more comfortable with a $50.00 per child or a total of $175,000 in new state aide. He also mentioned that this was the first time he had seen this version of the budget.

Ms. Karol, Language Department Chair stated that she did not understand how the district could find the money for a new language program when her budget had been cut from last year to this year and she does not have money to replace books that are 20 years old.

 Public hearing closed at 8:40 p.m.  

New Business

Freshman Soccer Presentation

Mr. Eames and Mr. D’Amore gave the Committee a presentation on starting a Freshman Soccer Team at the high school. It included a written proposal, parent emails and student letters. The cost of this program after the fees are implemented is approximately $3,000.

 Athletic Budget

Members received a copy of the FY08 Athletic Budget. There was a brief discussion on it tying out to the FY08 budget; parity between boys and girls sports; and money not budgeted in the past for tournaments. Mrs. Albert stated that the numbers for the new Freshman Soccer Program did not add up in the paperwork provided by the Athletic Director. She said cutting the secretary position to fund the salaries and needed items came to far less than the $12,000 cut. Some members said that having more than a 2.5% increase sent to the towns was not doable. Chairman Moran said that the funding from the state would be available in a few more weeks.

Chairman Moran stated that the Committee voted back in December that it was not required to have a supplemental ready for each of the versions of the budget. She said she would check the minutes from the December meeting to review the motion that was made and confirm what the committees decision was and that she would be sure to follow the committees’ vote. Chairman Moran also said that the assessments could not be provided until the State set the town’s minimum contribution. Ms. Blades said that she could not vote for a budget without the base and supplemental. Mrs. Albert commented that the budget was fair for student achievement.

 Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Baumgardner and seconded by Mr. Levine to have the athletic budget in the format that was used over the summer (excel spreadsheet created by sport). Motion carried. (unanimous approval)

 FY08 Technology Plan Budget

The proposed FY08 budget has a total of $150,389 budgeted for instructional technology hardware acquisition. In an attempt to provide equal instructional and student learning opportunities district-wide without adding additional funds, the technology integration specialists and Dr. McGinn have drafted an acquisition plan for consideration.

 The process included the examination of each school’s current inventory of instructional hardware. A review was done of each school’s current status relative to: teachers having access to a computer, the quality and capacity of each school’s instructional computer labs, the quality and number of computers in each school’s library/media center, each school’s capacity to provide students with access to a classroom based computer, and the availability of presentation carts and interactive whiteboards.

 Chairman Moran asked Dr. Livingston if the $30,000 cable grant was taken into consideration with the new technology plan. He said it was. Dr. McGinn stated that the goals was to bring the elementary school up to Merrimac’s level of computers in each classroom as this is not the situation now.

 Dr. McGinn will provide information about the ratio of students to computers in each of the elementary schools at the January 30th meeting.

 FY08 Fee Structure-Extra Curricular and Revolving Accounts

Dr. Livingston proposed that the elementary fees that vary from school to school be leveled out and balanced across the district over a two year period.

 Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Levine and seconded by Ms. Blades to direct the Superintendent to do an analysis and make recommendations around student activity fees related to assumptions, revenue, expenses and enrollments. There was a friendly amendment offered instead of increasing fees to go back to the lower amount for the analysis. Motion failed. (for: Blades, Levine)(opposed: Moran, Deveau, Corradino, Albert, Baumgardner, Fournier)(abstained: Baker, Piccolomini, Atwood)(for: 2.2)(opposed: 6.0)(abstained: 2.7)

 There was brief discussion on the before and after school fees. Member questioned why the fees were increasing when there is a balance in the accounts. The fees for this program are not consistent across the district. Mr. Levine question with an increase of 8% or 11% what is the increase in the service.

 Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Levine and seconded by Ms. Blades to have a before and after school rationalization for the January 30th meeting to include enrollment, existing expenses and existing revenue. This motion also included proposed program improvements being funded by the increase in fees. Motion failed. (for: Blades, Moran, Levine, Piccolomini)(opposed: Deveau, Baumgardner, Albert, Atwood, Fournier, Baker)(abstained: Corradino)(for: 4.4)(opposed: 5.4)(abstained: 1.1)

 Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mrs. Piccolomini and seconded by Mr. Deveau to approve the fees for the preschool and the kindergarten program as they are in the proposed FY08 budget which are the same as FY07 budget. Motion carried. (for: Blades, Moran, Fournier, Baumgardner, Corradino, Piccolomini, Albert, Baker, Deveau)(abstained: Atwood, Levine)(for: 9.0)(abstained: 1.9)

 

Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Baker and seconded by Mr. Levine to continue the meeting after 10:00 p.m. Motion carried. (for: Moran, Fournier, Baumgardner, Levine, Atwood, Corradino, Piccolomini, Albert, Baker, Deveau)(opposed: Blades)(for: 9.8)(opposed: 1.1)

 Motion/Vote

It was moved by Ms. Blades and seconded by Mr. Levine to have the Superintendent do an analysis of the athletic fees reducing the cost from 75% of the program to 73%.

 Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Baumgardner and seconded by Mr. Baker to table the discussion on fees. Motion carried. (for: Moran, Fournier, Baumgardner, Levine, Atwood, Corradino, Piccolomini, Albert, Baker, Deveau)(opposed: Blades)(for: 9.8)(opposed: 1.1)

 Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Baker and seconded by Mr. Atwood to table items C, E, and F on the agenda (out of district special education job description, CORI policy – second reading, and FY07 financial statements – general ledger and fund balances). Motion withdrawn.

 Mr. Deveau expressed concern about the assessments to the towns being 5.2%. Mr. Baker said the overall budget should be decreased $150,000.

 Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Baker and seconded by Mr. Atwood to table items C, E, and F on the agenda (out of district special education job description, CORI policy – second reading, and FY07 financial statements – general ledger and fund balances). Motion carried. (unanimous approval)

 Ratification of Unit D (ESP’s, CCP, Job Coach) Contract

Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Baker and seconded by Mr. Levine to ratify the Unit D Contract as presented to the School Committee (delivered) on January 3, 2007. Motion carried. (unanimous approval)

 Donation to Special Education Department

Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Baker and seconded by Ms. Blades to accept the donation to the Special Education Department. Motion carried. (unanimous approval)

 Executive Session

Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Baker and seconded by Mr. Levine to enter into executive session for the purpose of discussing contract negotiations and pending litigation. Motion carried. (for: Moran, Fournier, Baumgardner, Levine, Atwood, Corradino, Piccolomini, Albert, Baker, Deveau)(opposed: Blades)(for: 9.8)(opposed: 1.1)

 Adjournment

Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Baker and seconded by Mr. Levine to adjourn the meeting at 11:08 p.m. Motion carried. (unanimous approval)

 Respectfully submitted,

 Marianne Naffah

Recording Secretary

 


 January 30, 2007

PENTUCKET REGIONAL SCHOOL COMMITTEE

 

                                                                                                            High School

                                                                                                            January 30, 2007

 

Members Present: Chairman Moran, Mrs. Albert, Mr. Levine, Mr. Fournier, Mrs. Piccolomini,

Mr. Baker, Mrs. Corradino, Mr. Baumgardner, and Mr. Atwood

 Also Present: Dr. Livingston, Dr. McGinn, Ms. McWilliams

 Chairman Moran began the workshop at 7:32 p.m.

 Attendance was taken. Mrs. Grazio, Ms. Blades and Mr. Deveau were absent.

 Chairman Moran stated that the purpose of this meeting was for a workshop only to discuss the proposed FY08 budget. Dr. Livingston and Ms. McWilliams reviewed the changes with members. All members received an edited copy of the proposed FY08 budget and were given the opportunity to ask questions.

 Discussion followed:

 

  • Mr. Levine asked the following questions: 1. What are the top expense drivers? How are they changing year to year? How are we managing/attenuating increases? 2. What are the cost containment initiatives in this budget? 3. What are costs/benefits of new spending items? (new initiatives) 4. What are the relative priorities of new spending items – highest to lowest? 5. If this is year one of a five year window, what does year five look like? (revenues, expenses) Mr. Levine asked when he would receive the answers to these questions. Chairman Moran said she would be reviewing the agenda for the next meeting.
  • The budget presentation contained preliminary assessment figures.
  • Mrs. Corradino had questions with the enrichment program. Who oversees the program? What is offered?. What is the curriculum? Is there parity between the schools? Dr. McGinn will be working with the principals on bringing something to the Committee including the staffs’ certifications and qualifications.
  • Several members would like to see some data on the athletic budget. It will be discussed at the next meeting.
  • Mr. Fournier commented that the towns were impressed with the presentations and the parity in the schools.
  • Mr. Baker asked which budget would be voted by the Committee. Chairman Moran responded the general fund budget first and then the supplemental. Mr. Baker said that although the Committee has not voted grants and revolving in the past he feels the Committee should. Chairman Moran reminded him that the Committee does vote all grants and that the Treasurer oversees student activities.
  • Ms. McWilliams will be providing the Committee with an update on FTE’s.
  • There was a reminder that the budget must be voted by the Committee before March 1st.
  • There was a brief discussion on foreign language text books. Members questions how many students were enrolled in the classes and where has the money gone if they did not purchase textbooks. Dr. McGinn will provide the information at the next meeting.
  • The next meeting will also include a discussion on the capital plans and feedback from the regional finance advisory group.

 The workshop ended at 8:53 p.m.

 Respectfully submitted,

 Marianne Naffah

Recording Secretary


February 6, 2007

PENTUCKET REGIONAL SCHOOL COMMITTEE

 

                                                                                                            HighSchool                                                                                                February 6, 2007

 

Members Present: Chairman Moran, Mrs. Albert, Mr. Levine, Mr. Fournier, Mrs. Piccolomini,

Mr. Baker, Mrs. Corradino, Mr. Baumgardner, Ms. Blades, Mr. Atwood, Mrs. Grazio, and

Mr. Deveau

 Also Present: Dr. Livingston, Dr. McGinn

 Call to Order: Chairman Moran called the meeting to order at 7:39 p.m.

 Roll Call: Roll call was taken. The majority vote was 5.7. Mr. Baker arrived at 8:40 p.m.

The majority vote changed to 6.1.

 Ms. Teeters led the Committee in the Pledge of Allegiance.

 Agenda

Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Levine and seconded by Mr. Atwood to accept the agenda as amended.  The amendments were to add a discussion on the Business Update Report and the Superintendent’s Report.  Motion carried. (unanimous approval)

 Mrs. Grazio and Ms. Blades asked why the Superintendent’s Report and the Business Office Update are not on the agenda. Chairman Moran said they have not been in the past and they are for School Committee members only. Ms. Blades asked Chairman Moran to check that with the Open Meeting Law.

 Ms. Blades also asked about the incidents at the Page School regarding electric issues and smoke in the cafeteria. Chairman Moran will report to the Committee at the next meeting.

 Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Fournier and seconded by Mrs. Piccolomini to have the minutes reflected the time spent on each discussion in an effort to improve the time spent at the meetings and analyze  where the Committee gets “bogged down”. Motion failed. (for: Fournier, Piccolomini, Atwood)(opposed: Grazio, Blades, Levine, Corradino, Baumgardner, Albert, Deveau)(abstained: Moran)(for: 3.0)(opposed: 7.1)(abstained: 1.1)

 Minutes

Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Levine and seconded by Mr. Baumgardner to accept and file the minutes of January 16, 2007. Motion carried. (for: Levine, Fournier, Corradino, Albert, Baumgardner, Deveau, Piccolomini, Blades, Atwood, Moran)(abstained: Grazio) (for: 10.1)(abstained: 1.1)

 Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Levine and seconded by Mr. Baumgardner to accept and file the minutes of January 30, 2007. Motion carried. (for: Levine, Fournier, Corradino, Albert, Baumgardner, Piccolomini, Atwood, Moran)(abstained: Blades, Deveau, Grazio) (for: 8.2)(abstained: 3.0)

 Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Levine and seconded by Mr. Baumgardner to accept and file the Finance Subcommittee minutes of January 2, 2007. Motion carried. (unanimous approval)

 Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Levine and seconded by Mr. Baumgardner to accept and file the Finance Subcommittee minutes of January 16, 2007. Motion carried. (unanimous approval)

 Correspondence

Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Levine and seconded by Mr. Baumgardner to accept and file the correspondence. Motion carried. (for: Levine, Moran, Baumgardner, Corradino, Piccolomini, Fournier, Atwood, Deveau, Albert)(opposed: Blades)(abstained: Grazio)(for: 9.0)(opposed: 1.1)(abstained: 1.1)

 Dr. McGinn explained the principal’s search procedure. Some members expressed disappointment that in choosing the search subcommittee it was not advertised and made more public.  Some members agreed that the search should go beyond the parents and members of the school and that the administration should reach out to other community members. Ms. Blades mentioned that the PAC members should also have been included.

 Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mrs. Corradino and seconded by Mrs. Grazio to have a common protocol for the search committee and to have it advertised in the newspaper. Motion carried. (unanimous approval)

 Presentations

Sweetsir School

Mary Ellen Ramsey, Music Teacher, showed the Committee a video of student learning the process of a performance with instruments from start to finish.

  Pentucket High School Abigail Adams High School Scholars

There have been an additional nine students who have been awarded the John and Abigail Adams Scholarships. The recipients were Emily Antos, Madeline, Eames, Stephen Godin, Matthew Jayne, Diana Kelly, Chantel LaFrance, Brandon Lathrop, Stephen Lyons and Sarah Scutt. The students were invited in to the meeting to be recognized. All students were not in attendance.

 Public Comment

Several people spoke with regard to keeping German as a program at Pentucket. Some mentioned adding Mandarin Chinese or Arabic as the district already has 2 romance languages. High school students presented a petition signed by 150 people asking for the Committee not to dismantle German, they also discussed the numerous companies headquartered in German. The petition will be filed with the permanent record.

 New Business

FY08 Budget

Members were given the FY08 Proposed Maintenance Budget and a draft of a Five Year Capital Plan. Discussion followed:

  • Chairman Moran will name a Capital Planning Subcommittee at the next meeting. Members were asked to contact Chairman Moran if interested in participating on that subcommittee.
  • This capital plan is not included in the FY08 budget as it is a preliminary plan.
  • Dr. Livingston said that the draft capital improvement project lists from each building need to be considered by the new subcommittee and then shared with the town capital committees. Some of the elementary projects may wish to be presented to the towns for consideration at the Fall Town Meetings. The middle and high school projects need to be handled by the region perhaps through the stabilizations funds. In discussion with the district bond counsel, they felt many of these secondary school projects could be funded through the stabilization fund.

 The technology information given to members was in response to a prior question that further describes the computer ratio as computed by the state on category A computers.

 Athletic Budget

Members received the athletic budget which showed the FY08 projected costs and the projected revenues with a new fee structure. Mr. Difelice recommended the new fee structure. Currently the fee structure represents 75% of the cost of the sport minus the gate receipts. The new fee structure recommends a flat fee.

 Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Baumgardner and seconded by Mrs. Grazio to eliminate ice hockey. Motion withdrawn.

 Mr. Baumgardner asked if students from other towns were part of the ice hockey team. Mr. Difelice said there were. Mr. Baumgardner said that the program is too expensive for the district if students from outside the district are participating to keep the program running.  Mrs. Townes said that if we removed ice hockey the high school would have to removed a girls sport or find another boys sport to replace hockey due to the Title 9 restrictions.

 Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mrs. Albert and seconded by Mrs. Piccolomini to accept the proposed fee structure for the FY08 athletic budget. Motion carried. (for: Piccolomini, Fournier, Moran, Corradino, Baumgardner, Albert, Atwood, Deveau)(opposed: Levine, Blades, Grazio, Baker)(for: 7.9)(opposed: 4.1)

 Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Baker and seconded by Mr. Atwood to adopt the FY08 budget for the general fund in the sum of $31,457,895 allocated using the two step method. Motion failed. (for: Piccolomini, Fournier, Moran, Corradino, Deveau, Atwood, Baker, Albert)((opposed: Blades, Grazio, Levine, Baumgardner) (for: 7.6) (opposed: 4.4) The reason the motion failed is because this vote needed a two-thirds majority.

 There was a brief discussion:

  • Ms. Blades said that she could not vote a budget without information on the costs to the towns using both assessment methods and the base plus the supplemental.
  • Mrs. Grazio said that she has not seen the assessments and she does not know what this budget will cost the towns. Mrs. Grazio said she also had concerns with the teacher’s contract being unsettled and she has not seen the supplemental budget.
  • Mrs. Piccolomini said that the assessments were discussed at the January 30th worksheet and are as follows: Groveland – $219,688  Merrimac - $239,562 West Newbury - $151,061

 Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Baker and seconded by Mrs. Albert to change the order of the remaining agenda items. The change was to move the home school request and the donation to the next items. Motion carried. (unanimous approval)

  Home School Request

Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Baker and seconded by Mr. Atwood to approve the home school requested as presented by Dr. McGinn. Motion carried. (unanimous approval)

 Donation Atwood Family

Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Baker and seconded by Mrs. Corradino to accept the donation from the Atwood family for a Hewlett-Packard 5550DN Color Laser Jet Printer with supplies to the Central Services Office. Motion carried. (for: Baker, Albert, Deveau, Blades, Piccolomini, Fournier, Levine, Moran, Corradino, Baumgardner)(abstained: Atwood)(for: 10.4)(abstained: .8)

 Mrs. Grazio was not present for the three previous motions.

 CORI Policy

Motion/Vote/Amendment

It was moved by Mr. Baker and seconded by Mrs. Piccolomini to edit the first sentence to read: “It shall be the policy of the Pentucket Regional School District to obtain all available Massachusetts Criminal Offender Record Information (C.O.R.I.) from the criminal history systems board of prospective employee(s) or volunteer(s) of the school department including any individual who regularly provides school related transportation to children, who may have direct and unmonitored contact with children, prior to hiring the employee(s) or to accepting any person as a volunteer. Motion carried. (unanimous approval)

 Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Atwood and seconded by Mrs. Corradino to accept the CORI Policy for a second reading. Motion carried. (for: Piccolomini, Fournier, Moran, Baumgardner, Corradino, Atwood, Albert, Deveau)(opposed: Levine, Baker, Grazio, Blades)(for: 7.9)(opposed: 4.1)

 Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mrs. Albert and seconded by Mrs. Corradino to continue the meeting after 10:00 p.m. Motion carried. (for: Moran, Baumgardner, Corradino, Piccolomini, Fournier, Atwood, Baker, Albert, Deveau)(opposed: Levine, Blades, Grazio)(for: 8.7)(opposed: 3.3)

 Use of Facilities

Motion/Vote/Amendment

It was moved by Mr. Baker and seconded by Mrs. Corradino to amend and add to number 1 of the Use of Facilities Policy the following sentence: “If a request has been denied to use a school facility the person(s) have a right to appeal the decision to the School Committee. Motion carried. (for: Baker, Atwood, Fournier, Corradino, Grazio, Levine, Baumgardner, Blades)(opposed: Deveau, Albert)(abstained: Piccolomini, Moran)(for: 8.2)(opposed: 1.6)(abstained: 2.2)

 Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Baker and seconded by Mrs. Corradino to accept the Use of Facilities Policy for a first reading. Motion carried. (for: Moran, Baumgardner, Corradino, Piccolomini, Fournier, Atwood, Baker, Albert, Deveau)(opposed: Blades, Grazio)(for: 8.7)(opposed: 2.2)

 Mr. Levine was not present for the previous vote.

 Mrs. Grazio said she was concerned that the policy did not mention town groups. She also asked why the principals aren’t taking care of their own buildings.

 Out of District Special Education Job Description

Members received the job descriptions for the Director of Special Education and the Out of District Coordinator. Members were pleased with the reorganization of the job descriptions. Ms. Blades asked if the out of district coordinator can commit funds for the district. Ms. Fain said they could under her supervision. Ms. Blades also expressed concern of the out of district coordinator being part of the teachers contract.

 Executive Session

Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mrs. Piccolomini and seconded by Mr. Baker to enter into executive session for the purposes of contract negotiations. Motion carried. (for: Moran, Baumgardner, Levine, Corradino, Piccolomini, Fournier, Atwood, Baker, Albert, Deveau)(opposed: Blades, Grazio)(for: 9.8)(opposed: 2.2)

 Adjournment

Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mrs. Piccolomini and seconded by Mr. Baker to adjourn the meeting at 11:10 p.m. Motion carried. (unanimous approval)

 Respectfully submitted,

 Marianne Naffah

Recording Secretary


 

February 13, 2007                                                                                     

PENTUCKET REGIONAL SCHOOL COMMITTEE

 

                                                                                                            High School

                                                                                                            February 13, 2007

 

Members Present: Chairman Moran, Mrs. Albert, Mr. Levine, Mr. Fournier, Mrs. Piccolomini,

Mr. Baker, Mrs. Corradino, Mr. Atwood, Mrs. Grazio, and Mr. Deveau

 Also Present: Dr. Livingston, Dr. McGinn

 Call to Order: Chairman Moran called the meeting to order at 7:38 p.m.

 Roll Call: Roll call was taken. The majority vote was 4.5. Mr. Atwood arrived at 7:55 p.m.

The majority vote changed to 5.0.

 Mr. Deveau led the Committee in the Pledge of Allegiance.

 Agenda

Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Levine and seconded by Mrs. Piccolomini to accept the agenda as amended.  The amendment was to remove the Executive Session.  Motion carried. (unanimous approval)

 Minutes

Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mrs. Grazio and seconded by Mr. Baker to table the minutes of February 6, 2007. Motion carried. (unanimous approval)

 Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Levine and seconded by Mr. Baker to accept and file the Finance Subcommittee minutes of January 30, 2007. Motion carried. (unanimous approval)

 Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Levine and seconded by Mr. Baker to accept and file the Finance Subcommittee minutes of February 6, 2007. Motion carried. (unanimous approval)

 Correspondence

Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Levine and seconded by Mrs. Piccolomini to accept and file the correspondence as amended. The letter from Inge Buerger and the information from the Superintendent were held for discussion. Motion carried. (unanimous approval)

 Public Comment 7:45 – 8:20 p.m.

Several people (students, teachers and community members) spoke in favor of maintaining the German program as it is now. Although there was no opposition to Latin, people felt strongly that the German program is a feeder program and should stay in place beginning at the 7th grade level.

 Mr. Stasiuk and Mrs. Kastrinelis both spoke on behalf of the budget. They want to see it approved as soon as possible. Mr. Stasiuk said it was fair and reasonable. Mr. Labrecque, Groveland Finance Director, handed out data on three year revenue projections after conferring with Ms. Blais, West Newbury Finance Director, and Ms. McLeod, Merrimac Finance Director.

 Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Levine and seconded by Mrs. Grazio to have the German program remain in tact for 2007 – 2008 school year. Motion carried. (for: Grazio, Piccolomini, Fournier, Levine, Corradino, Atwood, Baker, Deveau)(opposed: Albert)(abstained: Moran)(for: 7.9)(opposed: .8)(abstained: 1.1)

 Discussion followed:

  • Mr. Atwood and Mr. Baker agreed that English is the language of business and that our

students need to be taught for the business world of the future and the district should consider introducing them to Spanish or Chinese.

  • Mrs. Grazio said that the survey should have been done with the community, parents and students before any decisions were made.
  • Dr. Livingston said that no positions would be eliminated. He is committed to improving student achievement and that there is data that proves that test scores have increase with students taking Latin.

Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Deveau and seconded by Mrs. Piccolomini to add Latin as defined in the FY08 proposed budget. Motion carried. (unanimous approval)

 Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mrs. Piccolomini and seconded by Mrs. Corradino to have the Superintendent look into all languages that are being offered and to do an analysis of what is out in other schools and revamp what is offered at Pentucket. This motion also includes continuing with the survey with the community and the staff. Motion carried. (unanimous approval)

 FY08 Budget

Estimated Assessment/Attorney Finnegan’s Opinion – There was no discussion.

 Supplemental Budget

Dr. Livingston said that the Supplemental Budget largely reflects new initiatives. There will be a savings in Special Education if the district contracts out special education transportation. Dr. Livingston would like to maintain one or two vehicles for the purposes of our courier service and for district maintenance service. Dr. Livingston would like to dispose of the remaining vans which would give the district approximately $60,000. Chairman Moran agreed and said that $24,000 could be removed from vehicle repair and $34,000 could be removed from special education transportation gasoline.

 Motion/Vote Amendment

It was moved by Mrs. Grazio and seconded by Mr. Levine to have lines 63 (Sped Vehicle Repair - $24,784.) and 64 (Sped Transportation Gasoline - $34,858.) be removed from the Supplemental Budget. Motion carried. (for: Piccolomini, Grazio, Fournier, Moran, Levine, Corradino, Deveau, Baker)(opposed: Atwood, Albert)(for: 8.2)(opposed: 1.6)

 Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Baker and seconded by Mrs. Piccolomini to have the district outsource special education transportation. The motion was modified to have the Superintendent bid this out and only proceed if it is beneficial financially. Motion carried. (unanimous approval)

 Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Deveau and seconded by Mr. Baker to accept the Supplemental Budget for $946,520.56. Motion carried. (for: Moran, Corradino, Piccolomini, Fournier, Atwood, Baker, Albert, Deveau)(opposed: Grazio)(abstained: Levine)(for: 7.6)(opposed: 1.1)(abstained: 1.1)

 Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Deveau and seconded by Mrs. Piccolomini to ask Mrs. Grazio and Mr. Levine for the reason whey they did not vote the Supplemental Budget. After reviewing the Parliamentary Procedure Chairman Moran did not choose to continue this motion or discussion.

 Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Deveau and seconded by Mr. Baker to adopt the FY08 budget for the general fund in the sum of $31,398,254.26 allocated using the two step method. Motion failed because there was not a two thirds majority vote. (for: Piccolomini, Fournier, Moran, Corradino, Deveau, Atwood, Baker, Albert)(opposed: Grazio, Levine)(for: 7.4)(opposed: 2.2)

 

  • Mr. Atwood commented that this is a 3.1% increase.
  • Mr. Levine said that he could not vote until the questions he asked have been answered. The questions were submitted at the January 30th workshop.
  • Chairman Moran asked for a motion on Mr. Levine’s questions. Mrs. Grazio asked why the motion was necessary.

 Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Atwood and seconded by Mr. Baker to direct the Superintendent to provide a one page spreadsheet with top level revenue and expense projections for the next five years. There was an amendment to direct the Superintendent to call Mr. Levine. There was a second amendment to have the projections done for three years instead of five. The second amendment was not accepted. Motion failed. (for: Corradino, Deveau, Atwood, Baker)(opposed: Grazio, Fournier, Moran, Levine, Albert)(abstained: Piccolomini)(for: 3.5)(opposed: 5.2)(abstained: 1.1)

 FY07 Budget Transfers

Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Baker and seconded by Mr. Fournier to approve Transfer # 021307-1

From: 101.2410.00.0530.305.00.2.00000, Textbook & Periodicals Reading , Middle School 471.00

          101.2410.19.0530.305.00.2.00000, Textbook & Periodicals Sped, Middle School     100.00

To:     101.2410.15.0530.305.00.2.00000, Textbook& Periodicals SS, Middle School          571.00

Reason: Three sets Nystrom Desk Atlas and one Activity Binder needed for a total cost of $1287.00

Justification: The middle School Principal stated that a Social Studies Grant was cut and we need to fund the items for use in our Geography and History instruction. This reflects a priority for Social Studies instruction and needed to support the state frameworks.

Motion carried. (for: Moran, Levine, Corradino, Fournier, Piccolomini, Atwood, Baker, Albert, Deveau)(abstained: Grazio)(for: 8.7)(abstained: 1.1)

 Motion/Vote

It was moved by Mr. Levine and seconded by Mr. Atwood to approve Transfer # 021307-2:

From: 101.2440.19.0400.000.00.2.00000, Contracted Service Sped District Wide    5,049.00

To: 101.5260.00.0543.000.00.3.00000, Umbrella Liability                                       5,049.00